Iowa Homeowners Deserve the Whole Truth About the Shamrock Roofing Decision
The Iowa Attorney General's Office is celebrating the Eighth Circuit's decision as a victory for Iowa homeowners. That is an extraordinarily incomplete description of what the Court actually ruled.
Yes, the Eighth Circuit upheld the facial constitutionality of Iowa's public-adjuster statutes and rejected Shamrock's vagueness challenges. But the Attorney General's announcement leaves out what may be the most consequential part of the decision for Iowa homeowners and contractors.
The Eighth Circuit REVERSED the District Court
The Eighth Circuit reversed the district court's dismissal of Shamrock Roofing's as-applied First Amendment claim and sent the case back for further proceedings. And the appellate court went considerably further than merely giving Shamrock another day in court.
The Court Examined What Iowa Actually Prohibited
The Court specifically examined Iowa's attempt to prevent Shamrock from telling homeowners that it would:
"assist [them] with the claims process"
help them "navigate the insurance red tape"
"assist with insurance claims"
walk them "through everything with insurance reimbursement"
The Eighth Circuit's conclusion could hardly be clearer: when Iowa prohibited those communications, it "regulated speech as speech." And the Court held that "such applications trigger strict scrutiny" — the most demanding standard of constitutional review.
The First Amendment is no word game. And the rights it protects cannot be renamed away or their protections nullified by 'mere labels.'
— Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals
Such applications trigger strict scrutiny.
— Eighth Circuit, on Iowa's prohibition of contractor speech about the claims process
The district court's failure to analyze how Iowa actually applied these statutes to Shamrock was error.
— Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals
Regulating Conduct vs. Regulating Speech
There is an important distinction between regulating the conduct of unlicensed public adjusting and regulating what a roofing contractor is permitted to say to its own customers. The Eighth Circuit recognized that distinction.
When someone's home has just been damaged by hail, wind, or a tornado, homeowners naturally turn to experienced roofing professionals for information about what happens next. Iowa attempted to characterize certain communications between those contractors and their customers as regulated professional conduct. The Eighth Circuit has now said that when the State applies these statutes to prohibit communications such as helping customers understand and navigate the insurance-claims process, the State is regulating speech — and the First Amendment applies.
The conduct of unlicensed public adjusting.
What a roofing contractor is permitted to say to its own customers about the insurance claims process.
Iowa wins on the facial challenge and vagueness claims.
Shamrock wins reversal of its as-applied First Amendment claim.
Shamrock has not yet won its ultimate First Amendment claim. The Eighth Circuit explicitly said that it "remains to be seen" whether Shamrock can prove the allegations necessary to obtain relief.
But neither did Iowa obtain the sweeping constitutional victory its announcement suggests. The Attorney General is entitled to celebrate the portions of the decision the State won. But Iowa homeowners are entitled to hear about the portion the State lost.
And Garen Armstrong and Shamrock Roofing are entitled to something even more important: the opportunity the district court previously denied them — to have their First Amendment challenge properly evaluated on its merits. That is precisely what the Eighth Circuit ordered.
Read the Opinion.
The Court's words speak for themselves.